Myanmar and the Dilemma of the Church’s Prophetic Witness

 

 

IMG_20171014_083858

Asia is home to all of the world’s major religious traditions.

I recently had the opportunity to visit Myanmar.  I was there as part of the Protestant Church of East Timor’s (IPTL) delegation to the Asia Mission Conference.  The Asia Mission Conference was initiated by the Christian Conference of Asia (CCA) which is an diverse group of churches across Asia.

I found out that I’d be accompanying my colleagues from IPTL in August.  I didn’t know much about Myanmar so I started reading as much as I could. And then on August 25th the Myanmar government began its military campaign against the Rohingya people of Rakhine State. And now the whole world is talking about what is happening in Myanmar.

From its inception, the CCA has been a voice for justice in Asia. Its diverse member churches know that because Asia is home to all the world’s major religious traditions, peace among religions is critical. Hence, CCA has addressed issues of justice and peace common to all Asian people regardless of religious affiliation.

myanmar mapThe theme of the Asia Mission Conference 2017 was “Prophetic Witness to the Truth and Light in Asia.” This theme was explored through presentations and small group reflections.  We discussed what it means to be a “prophetic witness” on issues like migration, human trafficking, economic justice, interfaith harmony, environmental concerns and peace building.

Based on that kind of content, I assumed the Rohingya issue would at least be a topic of discussion. Myanmar is a majority Buddhist country and the Rohingya people are Muslim. I thought that on the occasion of this multi-national gathering of Christian leaders, a statement of some kind responding to this international crisis would be issued.

I was wrong. In a 5-day conference focused on the Church’s call to be a “prophetic witness,” on a whole host of justice and peace issues, the Rohingya issue was hardly discussed. After a day or so this seemed like an elephant in the room. I started asking my Myanmar colleagues about it. We discussed it in our small groups and daily Bible reflections. What I discovered is that most Myanmar people, including Christians, support their government’s actions in Rakhine state. Indeed the Rohingya (they are called Bengali by most Myanmar people) are accused of various things including efforts to secure Rakhine State for the implementation of Sharia law, rejecting the Myanmar government’s offer of citizenship, armed insurgency and terrorism.

IMG_20171012_171011

Theological reflections and small group discussion on social issues facing all Asians were part of every session at the Asia Mission Conference.  My group had members from the Philippines, India, New Zealand, Thailand, Indonesia, Myanmar, Sri Lanka, Timor-Leste and Taiwan.

Silence on the Rohingya Issue

It seemed clear to me that people in Myanmar are getting different information about the Rohingya situation than what the rest of the world is reading from day-to-day.  Indeed from virtually everything I’ve read, it’s a horrific situation involving two parties with vastly disproportionate resources.  Yet the Myanmar Christian community, and so far the CCA, had nothing to say on this issue. I found this really troubling.  The theme of the conference was on “prophetic witness” and the whole world is now talking about Myanmar. Yet here we were, an ecumenical gathering of church leaders concerned with issues of justice and peace and we weren’t talking about it.

After reflecting on it for a few days, a few thoughts come to mind. First, Myanmar is a new democracy and although it has a civilian government, a lot of power is still in the hands of the military.  The Myanmar Baptist Convention hosted the Asian Mission Conference and it was the first time such a thing has been allowed in Buddhist-majority Myanmar. Thus, voicing opposition to a government policy that has the support of the average Myanmar citizen, not to mention the government and military, might have had serious consequences for Christians in Myanmar.

Second, it would be easy for foreigners to go to Myanmar and express their moral outrage at this situation with a bold statement of “prophetic witness” against what some people are justifiably calling a genocide – and then get on an airplane and leave. Such an act of “speaking truth to power” might be a feel-good response for those visiting, but it would leave the Myanmar Christian community to face any consequences that might result from such a statement — alone.

IMG_20171017_143441

Last year CCA made a pastoral solidarity visit to Pakistan.  Something like this might be possible in Rakhine state as well, but it would have to be convened by the Myanmar Christian community.

A quick anecdote: on day three of the conference I was approached by a young pastor from Pakistan. He introduced himself and when he found out I was from the United States wanted to tell me a story. He said, “I want you tell your people back home that when someone burnt a pile of Korans in America, Christians in Pakistan got killed.” He went on to share the same story about when a European artist drew a caricature of the prophet Mohammed. “Christians in Pakistan got killed.” He said it several times, apparently wanting to make sure I got the point.  I did.

I realize that no one reading this would think that burning Korans is a legitimate act of “prophetic witness.” But some people do! The point is that what some people consider an act of “prophetic witness” can have unintended consequences for other people.

Thirdly, it appears that in Myanmar’s Christian community, the notion of public theology has yet to emerge. What I mean by public theology is simply looking at social issue in light of our faith.  It would seen that in Myanmar, like in most American churches, religion is primarily for the edification of one’s personal life.  By saying this I don’t mean to marginalize the transformative aspects of Christian piety & spirituality of the Christian communities in Myanmar. Indeed, we in the West have a lot to learn from our Asian church partners when it comes to faith. It’s simply a reminder that public theology, like thoughtful social analysis, is something that has to be learned. And as several presenters reminded us, theology in the postcolonial world has to be de-colonized in order for that to happen.

IMG_20171015_094637

Christianity is very vital in many parts of Asia but often lacks the kind of public theology that would compel churches to speak prophetically on something like the Rohingya issue.

Which brings me to my last point. Lest we point the finger at the Myanmar Christian community for its silence on this issue, let us not forget that in the U.S. 80% of white evangelicals, 60% of mainline Protestants and 50% of Catholics voted for Donald Trump,  a leader whose personality and policies are the antithesis of the way of Jesus Christ. And long before Trump, U.S. churches have been sitting silently by through any number of horrific actions by our own government, apparently not noticing the contradiction between those actions and their own faith claims.  So when we think about the dilemma of “prophetic witness” faced by the Christian community in Myanmar, humility is probably in order. I’m not saying this to excuse Myanmar Christians or make light of the situation.  I’m sharing what I think might partly account for the Church’s silence on what is by all accounts, a horrific issue that should concern us all.

 

 

Advertisements

2 comments

  1. I have been sharing this post. It is beautifully, heartbreakingly written. It highlights a humanitarian crisis as well as calls us out for our own complicity within our own churches.
    There are times when the silence is absolutely deafening.

    Like

  2. Thanks Glen. It was strange to be there in the midst of all this. At the same time it was heartening to process the question with so many different people from across Asia. Not surprisingly the UCCP delegates were most insightful in the analysis and commentary!

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s